Opened 21 years ago

Closed 21 years ago

Last modified 15 years ago

#903 closed defect (invalid)

Monkey CD: CD tracks play in wrong order

Reported by: SF/bagobones Owned by: eriktorbjorn
Priority: normal Component: Engine: SCUMM
Version: Keywords:
Cc: Game: Monkey Island 1


Riped tracks to MP3.

The wrong track plays in all scenes accept on the chapter title screens (The text screen).

Double checked my track names and they all seem correct.

From Monkey Island Madness CD that also included Monkey 2.

Also no SFX play but I guess thats a known issue.

Ticket imported from: #756433. Ticket imported from: bugs/903.

Change History (8)

comment:1 by eriktorbjorn, 21 years ago

Sound effects should work in the CD version, but not the floppy version. It should play the correct music as well, unless your version of MI1 is substantially different from the one I bought.

Does it work when playing the tracks from CD instead of MP3? In that case, the MP3 files are almost certainly misnamed. They should be named track1.mp3, track2.mp3, ..., track24.mp3, but you said you already checked that.

I used to have a list of what each track corresponded to, but I can't find it right now. A few easily-identified pieces of music in my case include:

track1.mp3 The Voodoo Lady theme track4.mp3 Church music track7.mp3 Love theme track8.mp3 SCUMM Bar music track11.mp3 Circus music track17.mp3 Intro music (two tracks in one, really)

Are yours numbered differently?

comment:2 by SF/logicdeluxe, 21 years ago

Here is the tracklist and the corresponding scenes I once figured out on my multi lingual CD: 01. The game (CD-ROM track) 02. Voodoo Theme: House of Mojo, heading to Monkey Island, caves inside the giant monkey head 03. Fork on Mle Island 04. Jail, chasing Storekeeper 05. Chirch 06. Mle Island Map 07. Chapter Screen 08. Guybrush & Elaine Love Theme (introduction) 09. SCUMM Bar :) 10. Ghost ship's deck 11. LeChuck Theme: unused? (refered in room 77, but I did not figured out a way it would be played) 12. Circus 13. LeChuck Theme: leaving SCUMM Bar the 1st time, the wedding 14. LeChuck Theme: removing the Fester Shinetop costume 15. Monkey Island Map, outside giant monkey head 16. On board the Sea Monkey 17. Guybrush & Elaine Love Theme (continued) 18. Title Theme & Teaser 19. Stan's Previously owned vessels 20. LeChuck kidnaps Elaine 21. unused? (no reference at all) 22. Canibal village 23. Seashore & seagull noises: Mle Island dock, Monkey Island beach 24. Mle Island chirp & crackle noises: outside circus, Carla's house, treasure site, Troll, Smirk's, insult swort fighting, outside Meat Hook 25. bird's tweat on Monkey Island: fort, river fork, lake, monkey's home

Regular End Credits play 8, 17 and 13. CTRL+W End Credits play 12 and 13. I have not found any scenes with tracks 11 or 21 playing.

comment:3 by SF/bagobones, 21 years ago

Ok thanks for the track info. It looks like all the tracks are 1 off. The first track is the data track on the CD so all my rips start from track 2.

Funny Sam & Max worked fine with the numbers starting at 2. Still no SFX

comment:4 by eriktorbjorn, 21 years ago

Yup, it's easy to make the mistake to start the numbering from 2. Been there, done that, bought the T-shirt...

The music tracks on the Sam & Max CD aren't used by the game. At least not by ScummVM, and I've been told the original interpreter ignored them as well. They're a nice bonus, though.

Does that mean this bug can be closed, or does it still play the wrong music anywhere that you've noticed?

comment:5 by eriktorbjorn, 21 years ago

Oh wait, I forgot about the sound effects. Do sound effects work in any of the other games?

comment:6 by SF/bagobones, 21 years ago

Well after the tracks where all corrected I launched the game and the SFX started to work.

I think there should be a note in the Readme / FAQ about track numbering, as I would think most ripping software will number starting with the data track.

Your right, the CD audio is not used in Sam & Max, just tested it without the tracks. Played all the way though S&M worked very well. Very few glitches.

comment:7 by SF/bagobones, 21 years ago

Status: newclosed

comment:8 by Kirben, 15 years ago

Owner: set to eriktorbjorn
Resolution: invalid
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.