Opened 12 years ago

Closed 12 years ago

Last modified 12 months ago

#3355 closed defect (fixed)

BARGON+WEEN: Amiga+Atari versions' MD5s

Reported by: SF/pwigren Owned by: DrMcCoy
Priority: normal Component: Engine: Gob
Keywords: detection Cc:
Game:

Description

331b5fb8b17b778aa98ee0971da0937f disk1.stk
159422b68d1ef1894ca183a5b3f0d031 disk2.stk
7ee7c2ed5faa2ba686c404368cb8dcb1 disk3.stk
85c0e85a0cd4aa61d55a072eea0478f3 disk4.stk
a85dd830250198259baba0e71f4d45c7 disk5.stk
2d5afd08d6329ccd338f9d5c1362580f disk6.stk
200e264cf1a3861cf466408ff1df748d disk7.stk
8714e7f79ac07a55e92449094ac7b1fb intro.stk

These are all the relevant files for Bargon Attack Amiga version. The other files on the disks are Amiga executables, icons etc.

The compability page states that Amiga, Atari and DOS version are supported.

Ticket imported from: #1764174. Ticket imported from: bugs/3355.

Change History (18)

comment:1 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

Summary: BARGON: Amiga version MD5sBARGON: Amiga+Atari versions' MD5s

comment:2 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

While we're at it, here are the MD5s for the English Atari ST version. :)

331b5fb8b17b778aa98ee0971da0937f disk1.stk
159422b68d1ef1894ca183a5b3f0d031 disk2.stk
7ee7c2ed5faa2ba686c404368cb8dcb1 disk3.stk
85c0e85a0cd4aa61d55a072eea0478f3 disk4.stk
a85dd830250198259baba0e71f4d45c7 disk5.stk
2d5afd08d6329ccd338f9d5c1362580f disk6.stk
200e264cf1a3861cf466408ff1df748d disk7.stk
8714e7f79ac07a55e92449094ac7b1fb intro.stk

comment:3 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

Summary: BARGON: Amiga+Atari versions' MD5sBARGON+WEEN: Amiga+Atari versions' MD5s

comment:4 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

md5sum for the English Atari ST version of Ween: The Prophecy. These are all files except the .PRG executable. I'm not sure if the *.snd files are used (or will be used in the future).

309cc79213acf42413e99ef4199de838 disk2.stk
d2ad3d188ee8fd5f1820c54587559ee2 disk3.stk
dd333aea2ce6803bd68a1373004c5084 intro.stk
3c32fcee6b9a12d800bc3b3b14a0a033 music_10.snd
5d245e4b5ca14edded59257208d9a81a music_11.snd
5cc0bc46a00ca502113426ab7eca975d music_12.snd
4d4f06ae42dea9a235e018031ee78dec music_14.snd
dc60076a4f148e841c129761f08dec92 music__4.snd
0519857bae4498127fff8735675c3f8e music__5.snd

comment:5 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

I'd need the MD5s of the first 5000 bytes (if you're on Linux, try "head -c5000 $file | md5sum") of the intro.stk files. ScummVM should print that out if the version is not yet known, too.
Also, the file sizes of these files would be nice as well.

comment:6 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

Keywords: detection added
Owner: set to DrMcCoy

comment:7 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

File sizes:

236114 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk1.stk
354071 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk2.stk
302718 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk3.stk
358467 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk4.stk
341862 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk5.stk
317082 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk6.stk
312829 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/disk7.stk
269825 Bargon Attack (Amiga)/intro.stk
236114 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk1.stk
354071 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk2.stk
302718 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk3.stk
358467 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk4.stk
341862 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk5.stk
317082 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk6.stk
312829 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/disk7.stk
269825 Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/intro.stk
644451 Ween - The Prophecy (Amiga)/disk2.stk
685505 Ween - The Prophecy (Amiga)/disk3.stk
456570 Ween - The Prophecy (Amiga)/intro.stk
644451 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/disk2.stk
685503 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/disk3.stk
456570 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/intro.stk
6377 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/music_10.snd
5143 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/music_11.snd
11037 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/music_12.snd
6516 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/music_14.snd
13446 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/music__4.snd
13446 Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/music__5.snd

MD5 of first 5000 bytes:

569d679fe41d49972d34c9fce5930dda Bargon Attack (Amiga)/intro.stk
569d679fe41d49972d34c9fce5930dda Bargon Attack (Atari ST)/intro.stk
bfd9d02faf3d8d60a2cf744f95eb48dd Ween - The Prophecy (Amiga)/intro.stk
bfd9d02faf3d8d60a2cf744f95eb48dd Ween - The Prophecy (Atari ST)/intro.stk

As you see, the first 5000 bytes are identical in the Amiga and Atari versions of Bargon Attack but the whole intro.stk files are not.
In Ween - The Prophecy the whole intro.stk files are identical for Amiga and Atari version but the disk2.stk and disk3.stk differ.

ScummVM detect the Atari version of Ween as the Amiga version and then complains about "WARNING: Couldn't load instruments file!".

comment:8 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

Hmm, the MD5 sums you provided for the full files from Bargon Attack Amiga and Bargon Attack Atari ST are identical.
As far as I know, the file for Amiga and Atari ST could be completely identical, because the game scripts check the video mode to distinguish the system.
For Bargon Attack, it shouldn't make any difference whether the game is detected as an Amiga or as an Atari ST version, too. For Ween, it does, because different music files are provided for each version.

So, I've added your Bargon Attack version (as Amiga), that should work on both versions. Please try that with the latest SVN repository / the next daily build.
For Ween Amiga, I need the size and MD5 of the first 5000 bytes of the ween.ins.
For Ween Atari ST, I need the MD5 of the first 5000 bytes of music__5.snd.

comment:9 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

MD5 of first 5000 bytes:
7d1819b9981ecddd53d3aacbc75f1cc8 Ween-Atari/music__5.snd
d2cb24292c9ddafcad07e23382027218 Ween-Amiga/ween.ins

I didn't realize I should keep the *.ins files before because the datafiles page on the wiki said I should only keep *.stk. Should I also keep the .DUM files? In that case these files are in the Ween Amiga directory (except Amiga executables and icons):

644451 disk2.stk
685505 disk3.stk
456570 intro.stk
2183 mus0.dum
2179 mus1.dum
2614 mus2.dum
82990 mus2.ins
3160 ween.dum
87800 ween.ins

comment:10 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

> the datafiles page on the wiki said I should only keep *.stk
Ah yes, that was a mistake. Changed it. :)
The .ins is the instruments file for the music and the .dum are the music files. So yeah, you need them.

I've added the Ween version now, too, thanks. :)
Please check with the latest SVN version / next daily build.

comment:11 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

Great! Thanks! I will try it out soon. On the datafiles page, add that the Atari ST version should keep *.snd also.

comment:12 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

> On the datafiles page, add that the Atari ST version should keep *.snd also
Right, forgot that. XD

comment:13 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

Status: newpending

comment:14 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

This tracker item is pending response by the submitter; we
cannot continue processing it before that happens. As a
consequence, its status has been set to "Pending". It will
automatically revert to "Open" once a new comment is made to
this item. If no response is made within 14 days, it will
automatically be closed.

Thank you.

comment:15 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

Sorry, for not responding. I've tested the svn version and they work. Thank you!

comment:16 by SF/pwigren, 12 years ago

Status: pendingnew

comment:17 by DrMcCoy, 12 years ago

Resolution: fixed
Status: newclosed

comment:18 by digitall, 12 months ago

Component: Engine: Gob
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.